• Skip to site navigation
  • Skip to blog entries
  • Skip to archive page
  • Skip to left sidebar
  • Skip to right sidebar
  • Home
  • Classifieds
  • Subscribe
  • Purchase Photos
  • Newspaper Ads
  • Business Directory
  • Printing
  • Advertising
  • Forms
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Role of the newspaper

BanksNewsTODAY

XML RSS Feed mobile Mobile Alerts mobile Email Alerts
  • Top Stories
  • News
  • Public Safety
  • Opinions
  • Sports
  • Features
  • Obituaries
  • Classifieds
  • Public Notices

Role of the newspaper

Posted by
Mike Buffington
in Opinions
Friday, September 26. 2008
Comments (119)
One of the roles of a newspaper is to be a mirror for the community. Last week, The Banks County News mirrored something that was unflattering to some people in the community.

The story and editorial last week about the events following the funeral of a local teen who died in a traffic incident set off a wave of discussion in Banks County. In the debate, some condemned the newspaper for reporting and commenting about the situation.

For those who have not followed the issue, the essential facts are these: A popular Banks teen, Tyler Bush, was killed when he stepped out of a jeep and tried to run along side of it while moving at 30-35 mph. It was the third tragic death of a teen in the community from traffic incidents in the last 18 months. A few hours after his funeral, several dozen friends gathered in a field at his home on Sims Bridge Road. Along the public road in front of the house, a vehicle — or several vehicles — were “laying drags,” apparently in “tribute” to the boy. A woman driving down the road saw a car she said was “fishtailing.” She stopped, confronted the crowd and called 911. She later filed a lengthy account of the incident with the sheriff’s department, which we published verbatim last week.

We also published an editorial that argued that slinging a car around on a public road — laying drags, illegal drag racing, doing donuts, spinning-out, whatever — was not the appropriate way to honor a teen who had just died in a tragic automotive incident. Furthermore, we said that the community’s cultural mentality that approved of such a response was very troubling.

I authorized the story being published and wrote the editorial. I knew that there would be some in the community who would not like it.

But it was the right thing to do and many of the comments posted on our website illustrated, perhaps unwittingly, the point we were attempting to make — that using a vehicle as an emotional response to a tragedy was evidence of a deeper cultural problem in the community.

We stand behind that view. Consider the following comments posted to our website:

--“… the people laying the drag were grown up not children... the children were in the pasture while the grown ups laid drags There was nothing wrong with what happen….around here people care and we show it and we express our feelings the country way not the city way…The gentlemen who were driving the cars were grown men and they were this childs friends they did what they felt like doing…”

--“These teenagers & adults were friends and family of Tyler and they were dealing with his death in a matter that is not always common but was related to Tyler as they all knew him. … The fast cars, large trucks and mud seemed to be his heart and soul. They sent him out the best way they thought he would like to go.”

--“MIND YOUR OWN BUSINESS! You are in the county now. And yes, we do thing a little differently out here! If you don't like it, I can give you directions to Atlanta.”

--“The sad thing is that we've become so overpopulated in North Georgia - that country people can't grieve the way we want - we have nosey city folks telling us that is the "right" way to grieve or celebrate a life.”

--“I believe that if Tyler could say something here he would tell us that the burn out was a perfect tribute to him. I am not saying it was the safest thing to do.”

Amazing. While these are a minority of comments posted, they reflect something very wrong in our culture. What is truly appalling isn’t the response of teenagers. Teens will often respond irrationally in emotional situations.

But it’s very troubling that so many adults see no problem with people doing dangerous activities in cars on public roads as an emotional outlet to a tragedy.

And that was the point of our editorial last week; too many adults in the community have modeled behavior that condones immature automotive hijinks as being “normal” and acceptable.

It isn’t. Those who think laying drags on a public road is an appropriate response to a teenager’s death are mistaken. And those who attempt to deflect criticism by suggesting it is normal, or just “the country way” are also wrong. I’ve lived all my life in the country and laying drags isn’t a normal way of expressing grief.

All automotive deaths are tragic, none more so than when a child is involved. Nobody, lest of all this newspaper, minimizes that, or the pain the family and friends feel.

But to stand by silent would be to accept it as “normal.” We won’t do that. It’s wrong. It’s immature. It’s dangerous. It sends the wrong message to the young people of Banks County. It should not have happened.

Adults in Banks County need to send a message to their youth that horseplay and cars are deadly.
Keeping other young people alive, not slinging cars around, would be the best way to remember Tyler Bush.
Trackbacks
Trackback specific URI for this entry
No Trackbacks
Comments
Display comments as (Linear | Threaded)
#1 Anonymous on 09/26/08, 03:39 PM (Reply)
Mike Buffington, YOU ARE AN IDIOT......
#2 Anonymous on 09/26/08, 05:32 PM (Reply)
I would like to thank you not only for this weeks article but that of last weeks also. I read all the comments on this last week and was amazed at how many so called adults found that the tribute was right. Maybe they will see how dangerous a vehicle can be and that a child's life is a valuable and irreplacable.
#2.1 anonymous on 09/26/08, 11:34 PM (Reply)
I too read the comments. As for myself I was upset that the article was placed on the front page giving headlines to a ladies police report. When most people could not get coverage like that paying for it. It inflicted pain and suffuring on innocent people that was already feeling very much grieved over a senseless death. It seemed to be saying that anyone who was at the location was guilty for the actions of a few people. I think the wrong impression was gotten especially from the lady who filed the report. Most of the people that were there were there to take pictures and try to remember Tyler in a positive way not to hold a drag race to remember Tyler. But because of the article that appeared in the paper all the family and friends that were there were stamped as teaching our teenagers to be reckless with thier lives. That was not the case most teenagers can get those ideas from listen to the nightly news and looking at the front of the paper. Even the lady that was cursing the people and demanding authority got a benifit of doubt because when she was using foul language they did not take her apart for engaging in that type of behavior in front of a bunch of teens or was she also was teaching our teenagers something that was not very good for them But was she not dragged over the front page because of her of behavior.
All people that are arrested even the one caught in an act or considered innocent until proven guilty or does that just apply to the people with most influence?
#3 Anonymous on 09/26/08, 07:56 PM (Reply)
I applaud you Mr. Buffington it is time the adults in this county start acting like adults.
Please parents teach your child the value of life instead of being flat out STUPID.
#4 Anonymous on 09/26/08, 07:59 PM (Reply)
Hey Mike and all people who want to tell us how to act.... WHERE AND WHAT ARE YOUR CHILDREN OR YOUR HUSBAN OR YOUR WIFE DOING RIGHT AT THIS MOMENT ...... CANT COUNT FOR EVERY MINUTE OR EVERY ACTIONS CAN YOU
#5 TM on 09/26/08, 08:34 PM (Reply)
I think I must be missing something. After reading the
comments on the original articles, it seems to me that
the main issue was the fact that the woman, whatever her
name was, got out of her car, confronted a grieving mother,
cursed, and made a general pest of herself, when she should
have simply called 911 and let the sheriff handle it from
there. I don't think the issue was that people were
"drag racing", the issue was the way she handled herself
and that was the reason people were so angry at her.
Until she's offered a job as a traffic controller,
perhaps it would be better if she allowed the sheriff's
office to do their jobs and for her to mind her own business.
She had no authority to get out of her car in the first place,
and she certainly had no authority to curse a grieving
mother. It was clear that she was just a busy body trying
to make a name for herself. I've seen so many like her and
each time I do, I wonder at their very nerve and self-
rightous attitude. Lady if you're reading this, can you
honestly say that you have one single friend in this
world. I feel sorry for you, but then I figure this is
how you fill your time - minding other people's business.
What a way to live!!!
#6 Anonymous on 09/26/08, 09:00 PM (Reply)
Thank you Mike for taking a stand on this issue.So many teens are getting injured and killed in wrecks in this county.By alot of the comments from parents accepting this behavior, I just pray to God that a tragic accident doesn't claim the life of their son ,daughter or another loved one.I have witnessed the pain in everyone of those 3 families that have lost a child .It is HELL. We all need to find a solution to this problem BEFORE it claims another life.Again thank you for your articles.
#7 leopardmom14 on 09/26/08, 09:26 PM (Reply)
I personally had more of a problem with the fact that the article was one sided, and on the front page of the paper one week after Tyler died. There should have been an article this week allowing Tyler's friends and family that were involved to respond. I think you are missing the point of why people were so upset about the article.
#8 msc on 09/26/08, 09:35 PM (Reply)
Why can't you just drop it! Let Tyler's family and friends go on with there lives. No, I'm not from Banks County, but I knew Tyler and he was a great kid! It may not have been the right thing to do (if they were doing as you report) but let it go. The more that is said the more pain you cause. Everyone just pray for Tylers family and friends and some the talking. Tyler was loved by many and will be missed!
#9 Anonymous on 09/26/08, 10:17 PM (Reply)
I have observed that it is not necessary for people who have sensible views to use all upper case letters, vulgar words, threats, and the like to make a point. People, I am not a Banks County native and if some of you are an example the populace, then I don't want ever to be. Mike Buffington is just doing his job; keeping the public informed about what is happening in the community. If the news happens to bring to the attention of the public things that are happening that a few would rather not be brought out, tough. If you don't want everyone to know what you're doing, don't do it. If you make a mistake and the paper reports it, don't curse and act a fool. That just proves that you are ashamed of your actions. Keep up the good work Mr. Buffington. The public has a right to know.
#10 Mom in Banks County on 09/27/08, 10:21 AM (Reply)
As a mother I was horrified at the tragedy of Tylers death. I was thankfull that someone in the community cared enough to try to stop something else from happening. If anyone saw one of my children participating in dangerous behavior I would pray they would stick their nose in. That is the real county way, neighbors looking out for neighbors.
#11 Anonymous on 09/27/08, 05:00 PM (Reply)
Apparently there are those in the community that think they are much better than everyone else. These people have to make others out to be inferior, or ignorant to make their point. No, the events that occurred were not safe, but things have totally been blown out of proporton. Mr. Buffington, what are you trying to prove? Its not going to bring the teen back by fanning the flames. Let it go . . .Get over it and lets move on. We can remember Tyler, but we need to forget about all the controversy.
#12 SiDonna Marlow-Odum on 09/27/08, 05:46 PM (Reply)
As a Friend of Tylers Family and Nana Belvas daughter, everyone of you need to sit down and think about what you are saying....You are judgeing the way someone grieves.
Who are any of you to judge, isnt that GODS place not man???
Who are you to tell anyone how to act?
How to feel?
I watched Tyler grow up, He was a wonderful gentleman, he had a loving spirit, if he didnt we wouldnt be upset the way we are,
Ever one makes it sound like Tyler went out on that Sunday to get into a ACCIDENT (the deffinincition of that is something that you dont plan on happening) and breaking his momma's heart that is the last thing he would have ever done.
He was a teenage boy out with friend having a good time....This isnt anything any of us have never done before,he was having one last day of summer fun and died that is it thats the story we have no more Tyler.

So I never get to go to my moms and her tell me something Tyler has done, like winning a cattle show with his grandfather (Gene Hart), Or about where Tyler and Rita went on vacation, or where she seen him that week... I will never get to see him down at Bankscrossing going thru a drive thru with his buddys, or seeing him in his muddy truck and thinking I remember the days when I was foot loose and fancy free... do you remember.....

This is what Im gonna miss.

And all of you that want to keep telling us what we did wrong, My Mama always said
"You need to sweep under your on back steps before you come sweeping under mine"
#12.1 Jamie on 09/30/08, 11:29 AM (Reply)
The point here is that they were doing something illegal. No one is trying to tell them how to grieve. If they wanted to go mud bogging or something like that to honor his memory and what he enjoyed doing, let them do it on private property, not on a public road where other could get hurt.
#12.2 homer banks (Homepage) on 10/01/08, 11:41 PM (Reply)
Mike you have done a great job trying to open the eyes of our town. Drag racing on our public roads is by far stupid. We have a place here to do that its a lot safer! Miss marlow you need a job cause your opinions are just ignored and ignorant you need to get a life! We lost 5 teens my 9th grade year here at BC. That was a horrible year for us and if adults had stepped in 4 of those lives might have been saved! Its never ok to use horse play behind the wheel by a teen or adult. That indeed was a retarded idea that day accidents are accidents and they do happen everyday. I know the bush and hart family very well! I miss Carlton hart gene's brother he was a great man I pray that peace will find this family. I also pray we can teach our youth death can happen at a young age too! We should stop looking at all the drama and find a way to educate our youth they are our future county leaders. I love banks co and I will never leave her side. Let's band together and come up with a plan! This has been a rough year... Why are we making drama? Let's honer these lost souls by comming together if you have a ppion tell a story about how and what made you open your eyes! I lost my best Friend on McDonald circle Rd when he hit a truck head on due to him driving to fast and not being a experienced driver. Rip Ben Clark! We lost another on a atv rip j.w and rip benji Ferguson! Rip Thomas pressley! And rip Phillip! I am guilty as well I have raced all over this county I was dumb but thank god people around here told my dad my every move! He would take my keys and make me walk but so what it saved my life thanks to the folks that sent that message I might have hated you back then but you cared about me more than I could have known! Look teens these are the best years of your lives don't waste them by being stupid racing is fun no doubt but go to the drag strip. If you want to do something to impress each other be smart and stop and think is it safe! I love our teens its a constant reminder of how blessed I am!
#12.2.1 SiDonna Marlow-Odum on 10/02/08, 09:28 AM (Reply)
First of all im not ignorant im pissed at the fact that the bcn put on the front page how bad the teenagers were acting that day and my point is that it wasnt teenagers acting stupid it was grown ups and who the hell are you to call me ignorant you dont know me.....
I have a education a collage one at that i have traveled the world thanks to my father... and can you figure out when reading my comments that my point is leave the teenagers alone that were there that day they didnt do anything wrong it was a grown up......
you judge me as ignorant.....then read this you who judge another do not define that person but you define yourself

I guess your just as ignorant as I
#13 justa thought on 09/28/08, 01:40 AM (Reply)
Maybe,it's who you are and the connections you have with with your employees whether a story gets published ..evidently Mike Buffington as part owner of Mainstreet News does care about some peoples feelings,maybe if these people in the pasture had guns and moonshine,they would not have made the front page.It looks like you have to be arrested for a story to be kept out of this paper..,
#13.1 A Loyal Employee on 09/28/08, 06:17 PM (Reply)
I have sat and read each and every one of the comments on this website. As for those of you who call Mike Buffington stupid, I wish for once you could walk in his shoes. You would never be able to fill them. You would not be worthy to even try. He is a very well educated man who comes from a very loving and caring family. When he was growing up, his parents taught them the meaning of values and morals. That is something that I can say I still see in him today. I work with Mike every day and I have had things happen to me and my family that were reported in the paper just like everybody else. He is honest in the stories that he reports and his editorials. He is a very loyal and fair employer. Until you can measure up to him, I'd say you need to keep your negative comments to yourself. Mike is looking out for the well-being of all our young people and you should be happy that he is concerned about your children........
#14 Mary on 09/28/08, 09:08 AM (Reply)
Mike, I thank you for your firm stance on the situation.
I have two teenage boys that I could not imagine losing to a "fun day" gone wrong. While there are so many uncontrollable reasons you can lose a child, there are things we can control. Educating our young drivers and arming them with practices to remain safe should not be a "country" or "city" way of life.
Although I did not know any of the three who have died in the last 18 months, my heart dropped each time I heard; I cannot imagine the pain those families must be going through, and driving across Ashley's road memorial still brings tears to my eyes. What would be harder to take is another life hurt or lost senselessly in an activity meant to honor Tyler on a public road. Could the family and friends not organize an event in his name at a local mudbog or the Atlanta Dragway? To host an event in his name for an activity he so loved in a safer place would also be an outlet to grieve...but safely, to help prevent another mother from losing her child.
Maybe the concerned citizen did not conduct herself in the most appropriate manner...but when people believe they are suddenly in an unsafe situation, they do not always act calmly. However, had she behaved in that manner and stopped another type of reckless or potentially dangerous situation that everyone deems as dangerous, she would be hailed a hero today. I personally think she did the right thing by stopping the unsafe practices, but cannot speak to how she did it...sometimes adrenalin kicks in and you do what has to be done right then.
The division on whether the lady should have stuck her nose in or not, whether the family and friends should have gathered to engage in this particular tribute or not, or whether the paper should have printed the story or not are all overshadowing the fact that Banks County has lost three beautiful lives in the last 18 months while teens were engaging in unsafe driving practices. The school cannot be held solely responsible for teaching and exemplifying good driving practices for our teens. Parents and other adults are also responsible to model safe driving. I hope the community can put aside the country/city differences and come together on preventing future losses.
#15 Allyson Brannon on 09/28/08, 04:10 PM (Reply)
As a friend of Tyler's and an 18 year resident of Banks County, I think to raise an issue like this while people are still grieving is despicable. Regardless of the fact that what that woman did was completely inappropriate, everyone has their own personal way of honoring someone they loved.

We've grown up with a drag strip in our backyard; a drag strip at which at least one of our family members, friends, if not our own selves have raced. Cars and trucks are a part of who we are in Banks County, everyone knows a little something about them.

When a soldier dies in battle, we honor him/her by shooting guns...does that also reveal a deep-rooted, troubling mentality of the armed forces? No. And to suggest such a thing is ridiculous.

I go to school in Gainesville, and the way things are done there are very different. When my friend Evan King died, also at 17, we honored him by painting the rock and numerous other things. There, that is a time honored tradition.

In banks county, we do not have as many creative outlets to honor and remember someone by. Our traditions are our small town, country ways. To criticize the way we, as his friends and family, see fit to honor Tyler is rude and distasteful.

Did you know him?
Do you even know banks county?

Maybe we value different things.
Maybe you see us as ignorant.
Maybe you just think we do not know any better because we are "small town".

Well let me educate you: I attend Gainesville High School, have a 3.8 GPA, and plan on attending either Sarah Lawrence or Agnes Scott. Ignorance is not something I succumb to. I am proud to be a part of this "small town" community, I am proud of who we are and what we stand for.

We lost someone we loved, can't you just let us be?
#15.1 Mike Buffington, Publisher on 09/28/08, 05:14 PM (Reply)
Allyson: You make my point very clear with your comments. Like too many young people, you have come to accept the idea that slinging a car around on a public highway is somehow a "normal" and appropriate way to "honor" someone who has died in an auto accident. You are wrong. The message some adults are sending you and your peers is wrong. To suggest that Banks County lacks "creative outlets to honor and remember someone by" is an insult to the community. Until the community stops telling you and your peers that it's OK to use cars as an emotional outlet, more young people will die. That is everyone's concern and is the very reason we and others have chosen to speak out about this problem.
Mike Buffington
Publisher
#15.1.1 Deana on 09/28/08, 07:14 PM (Reply)
First off, Mike Buffington I'm amazed you have the
audacity to tell someone else that they've "insulted the
community"! I believe that I speak for many others when
I say that you not only insulted this community but
EMBARRASSED us all when you allowed Ms. Schmid's view to be
printed on the front page of the local paper. The sad
thing is, had you and your team of "reporters" appropriately reseached Ms. Schmid's story, this article, nor the 2 last
week would've been necessary. Unfortunately, you failed to
do that! Here's a thought, next week
find another topic to inaccurately report
because some of us are trying to grieve the loss of Tyler.
#15.1.2 Mark on 09/28/08, 08:10 PM (Reply)
Mr. Buffington,

I almost feel as if this newspaper isn't worthy of a response.

Were there events which occurred that day which were illegal, dangerous, and wrong? Did some people act immature? From all accounts I have heard yes, there were and at least one act was performed that broke the law. Even these comments which you have chose to quote admit that. With this said, the question which is raised concerns the role of a newspaper. As a news outlet, is it your role to put a spin on a story and report it one way, or is it your job to report both sides of a story and let the readers interpret what happened and form their own opinions?

I believe much of the outrage related to this stories printing is simply due to bad reporting. Most of the comments to last weeks story weren't anger at the event being reported on, instead they were anger that only one side of the story was reported. You should seriously have considered how one sided a letter to the editor would be before making it your front page story.

Sure, you have the right, nay the obligation, to write editorials which have been spun to highlight social issues but the reporting of events on the front page of a paper should be reserved for recording all the facts of a story. Much of the controversy and negative feelings toward the Banks County News which have spawned as a result of this story would have been avoided had the opinion of anyone in that field received near the amount of attention given to Ms. Schmid's police report. Instead, outrage has been fueled by irresponsibly reporting the events as recounted by one woman, who obviously has disagreements with other people who also witnessed the unfolding of the event.

The root of the outrage isn't that an unflattering event was reported. Instead, the anger from most Banks Countians is that the newspaper immaturely jumped on a story which would knowingly cause controversy with out receiving each side. Next time save everyone a little anguish and try to do what the media should do-report a story and not an opinion.

Respectfully,

Mark
#15.1.2.1 Mike Buffington, publisher on 09/28/08, 08:56 PM (Reply)
Mark: Thank you for your comments. If this had been some kind of political debate or controversial public issue, I would agree with you. But this was a police incident report and that's a different situation. We could, of course, have simply run the incident as a blotter item, ie. "A woman reported drag racing on Sims Bridge Road." Nobody was arrested and in those cases, we generally don't give many details nor do we name those involved. In this incident, however, we did give the incident details and named the person giving the report, both of which were done to allow readers to see the unfiltered report and to know who filed it so they could, as you suggest, form an opinion about the validity of the report. Since publishing the story, no one has challenged the allegations she outlined; in fact, most of those commenting on the matter have verified her report. But there's another aspect that I think got people riled up and that was the high-profile display the story was given on the front page. Some people saw it as being insensitive or as reflecting poorly on the community. While I understand those concerns, our decision to give this story a high-profile was done because we believe it represented a community problem that is much larger than the event itself. That problem, as we have said in an editorial and as I outlined in the above column, is that some adults in Banks County are passing along to children in the community an immature attitude toward the danger inherent in automobiles. Had we buried the story as some would have liked, there would have been no further discussion about that issue. Both sides of this issue have had an opportunity to have a say, as the numerous blog comments attest. And we have welcomed letters to the editor on the subject; but so far, nobody has written any letter to the editor about it. That, too, is telling. The purpose of having highlighted the story and writing the opinion comments about the underlying issue was to put a spotlight on what we see as a major problem in Banks County and to get the community asking questions about the issue. Hopefully, this discussion will help prevent another teen tragedy that we have so sadly had to report three times over the last couple of years.
#15.1.2.1.1 Mark on 09/28/08, 09:32 PM (Reply)
I would be forced to argue that, as presented, the facts surrounding the case are controversial. Sure, some of the blog postings affirm that illegal activities happened. The question is how many times did an illegal event occur and how did Ms. Bush and the other adults who where present respond? This information was left out, evidently, because it would not have displayed the immaturity which you claim to be rampant in Banks County's culture.

The police report is not considered to be fact. It is indeed a legal document but nothing attests to the accuracy of such document. The police report records the account of a witness, who may or may not have known the happenings of the entire event and who may not have even reported them accurately had she been there to watch it all unfold.

Everyone views the world a little differently and therefore views what happens in the world differently. Within the bounds of the law, we are all entitled to this right. However, as Banks County's primary source for news the paper should report on varying viewpoints and not just one.

People were not riled up because the story received front page coverage. People are riled up because Ms. Schmidd's story received front page coverage and not both sides of the controversial issue.

You have earlier ceded that you were aware the article would cause a disturbance amongst Banks County citizens. You knew it would be controversial, yet still decided to immaturely resort to one sided reporting because it would generate interest.

I personally have no interest in the particular matter at hand. I didn't know the Bush family, Tyler, or any of the other teens which Banks County has recently lost. Because of this some people may tell me to get my nose out of their business and let them handle you. However, as I see this particular issue of the Banks County News' reporting, it is an issue which affects every citizen of Banks County. Everyone, including Ms. Schmidd and the Bush family, deserve fair and accurate reporting. This article is clear evidence we aren't receiving it.

I think many of the posts which were made last week by the supporters of the Bush family were attempting to make this point. However, they were unable to separate their emotions associated with the lost of a loved one and the insulting reporting enough to accurately communicate their message. Instead, you allowed them to play into your ploy and to angrily post flame after flame on the blog response until you had enough ammunition to attempt and finish them off this week then you closed comments.

But to stand by silent would be to accept it as “normal.” I won’t do that. It’s wrong. It’s immature. It’s dangerous. It sends the wrong message to the citizens of Banks County. It should not have happened.
#15.1.2.1.1.1 Mike Buffington, publisher on 09/28/08, 10:37 PM (Reply)
I disagree. People were upset because the story WAS accurate and it portrayed a less-than-perfect scene of how a few in the community chose to respond to a tragedy. You seem to have confused the message with the messenger and like so many, decided to shoot at the messenger when you didn't like the message. Everyone has had an opportunity to have their say about the story and the underlying attitudes. To suggest we have only allowed one side to be told is wrong. All sides have posted dozens of comments, although no one has yet signed their name to a letter to the editor. Perhaps you will be the first?
#15.1.2.1.1.1.1 Mark on 09/29/08, 12:09 AM (Reply)
I am still quite uncertain as to how you can still claim this story was reported accurately. Again I will state that accurate reporting includes both sides of a story. Sure, many people have been able to post their responses and feelings to the story via this online blogging tool. I do commend you and the paper for the recent updates to your website which make this possible. However, if you examine the population of Banks County, what percentage of its citizens do you think actually utilize the internet? I feel like the percentage is even less when you consider how many use the internet as a source of local news. Consider the many people which read the print version of this article and never had the opportunity to read the electronically posted replies. Shouldn't the other side of the story have received the same treatment(ie, printed on the front page and edited by a professional) that Ms. Schmidd's received?

Possibly the story was reported accurately but we will never know because we only got one side of it.

And by the way, I am not shooting the messenger for delivering a bad message. The intentions of your message are great and commendable. I think your strong stance despite public backlash demonstrates a large degree of character. As I said before, I simply feel that you were aware the article would be controversial yet still failed to give both sides equal treatment.
#15.1.2.1.1.1.1.1 Mike Buffington on 09/29/08, 09:53 AM (Reply)
We did talk to the sheriff's department about the incident, so we did not just take one person's word for it. Should we have consulted with the teens who were there that day? I'm not sure that would have added any information that we didn't already know about. And I've not see anything in any of the comments or from phone calls that leads me to think the story was inaccurate. I think those who didn't like it either saw no problem with the events of that day, or thought we were being insensitive to do any kind of reporting given the emotional circumstances that surrounded it. Did we know it would be controversial? Of course, we knew some would not like it. It would have been easier to have just ignored the entire matter.... easier, that is, until we have to report on another teen auto death in the community. Hopefully, the highlighting of this issue will start a process of shifting some attitudes about teens and the use of cars as playthings in the community. Guess we'll have to agree to disagree on the form of the story which reported it.
#15.1.2.1.1.1.1.1.1 Mark on 09/30/08, 04:29 PM (Reply)
Apparently we could debate the issues of accurateness and good journalism until the end of time and your opinion would never change. The strength of your stance is admirable however I despise such a closed mind on a man as intelligent and educated as you are.

Of course I wouldn't expect you to interview one of the teens in the field, but maybe you could interview one of the adults that were there? Ms. Schmidd's police report stated that some of the people in the pasture indicated they were over the age of twenty-one. As the posts made in this blog and the blogs of the other two articles have shown, I am certain that you would have uncovered information that you didn't know at press time had you interviewed one of the adults present.

If you consulted the police department on the events which happened it is certainly not evident in the article. All that is displayed there is the police report, not any testimony of the officer which responded to the scene.

I'll grant you and the many concerned parents who have responded to these articles this: If the facts you reported are indeed accurate of the events happening, then there is an issue which needs to be addressed. However, I just don't think the readers of the BCN received the full details of that day. I feel like the events may have occurred differently than was portrayed in the article published.

I'll even give you that the issue of unsafe driving and how our culture promotes that to our teens needs to be addressed. Just once again, I don't think the facts of this particular day highlight that concern the way it is made to appear by this series of articles.
#15.1.2.1.1.1.1.1.1.1 Mike Buffington on 09/30/08, 05:26 PM (Reply)
There's little doubt that the events of that afternoon were larger than just what was happening on the road. But whatever was taking place on the private property was secondary to the reporting of the events on the road itself. The woman who filed the report used the term "drag racing" which has been questioned by some of these comments from those who claim people were just "laying drags." Does it make a difference and should we dig into the details to see there was racing or laying drags? Either way, an automobile(s) was being used illegally and perhaps dangerously on a public road in an emotional response to a tragedy. That is the real issue here. From what I have been able to see, the article was an accurate picture of what took place, although it was certainly not an exhaustive rendition of every aspect of the gathering that afternoon. If there's another side missing from this, I have yet to find it.
We are continuing to look into what is happening in Banks County regarding teens and automobiles and if there may be other related problems. I've received a lot of calls from people who paint a very distrubing picture about that issue in the county. I do appreciate your concerns and feedback. We do sometimes make mistakes; but on balance, I think the article was accurate.
#15.1.2.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1 Mark on 09/30/08, 05:46 PM (Reply)
I have no dispute that something illegal happened that day. The dispute I have is with what happened illegally. Some of the posts made have stated that one person burnt out, did a doughnut, and drove off. This is the side of the story which I would like to have seen more comment on in the paper.

Who exactly performed the illegal stunts? How many times? What were the possible responses of the adults there? How did the adults respond? Consider the answers to these questions and maybe that day wasn't as bad as portrayed, maybe the adults present could do nothing to stop the man who apparently drove off. But the newspaper doesn't report that as the case because they didn't ask the adults there or for that matter, anyone who witnessed it all.

My question is this: Were there any drag racing, drags laid, burnouts, whatevers after Ms. Schmidd appeared on the scene? All she reports seeing is the black marks shown in the picture, smoke, and almost being hit by a car coming around a curve. With those facts, how could Ms. Schmidd have been in a position to report that teens were drag racing? How can she refute the idea of one car being driven by one man as I earlier stated that some posts have indicated happened? She didn't see the event in its entirety but her word is taken as truth to what happened. That, to me, is not just seems wrong.
#15.1.2.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1 Mike Buffington on 09/30/08, 06:10 PM (Reply)
Fair enough. The problem is that there are 100 different versions of what was happening; the photos, some of which were not published, showed multiple black marks, so it appears to be more than just one single car. Some people claim they weren't paying attention to the cars while others, including the woman who stopped, say people were cheering. I wonder, if these people didn't expect to see some cars showing out in some manner, why were they lined up and down the fence? What were they expecting to see along the road that afternoon, a parade? Moreover, had this woman not stopped, how many other vehicles were in a holding pattern to do their tribute "burnout?" (She said several were along the side of the road.... were they awaitng their turn?) All of these questions are almost impossible to answer and were beyond the scope of the story.
You make a good point that her version of the events was the one published. That's because she filed the only police report. Shouldn't law enforcement been the ones asking the questions you raise here? If they had, we would have been glad to quote from those as well. We did quote the sheriff who said the cars from the road had left when deputies got there. My reporters were not at the scene at the time this happened, so like virtually all such incidents, we depend on law enforcement records as the primary source of information.

Regardless of the exact details, it's very apparent that a car, or several cars, were being or had been slung around on a public road in someone's warped idea of a tribute to a young man who himself had just died from a tragic automotive incident. I don't believe I'm the only person who finds that very, very strange and symptomatic of a much deeper community problem.
#15.1.2.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1 SiDonna Marlow-Odum on 10/01/08, 09:12 AM (Reply)
My problem with the whole artical is that you gave her a front page not just a front page but the second page also...and there were no teenagers on the road they were in the pasture passing out T-Shirts and stickers that is how they were celebrating Tylers life in the Pasture....
Mike did you know that Tyler only missed 2 days of church in his life...
did you know that him and his grand-father showed championship cattle.....
did you know that his cousins who were younger then him looked up to him.....
did you know that he made may mother smile everytime she seen him........
Did you even bother to ask someone who Tyler was or what he was all about.......
And why was the woman that got out cussing Rita and everyone else there allowed the front page..........
where is Tylers front page......
And where do you get off writing that Rita had bad judgedment...
me personally if I had just burried my child i dont think judgement would be the first thing on my mind.....and if some women got out of her car and started cussing me I can just about tell you she would have got her a** beat that is about all the judgement you would get from me if this had been me

But I will tell you this much Im very pissed at you and at Jennifer Schmid you have both put a Drag Mark on the day we were celebrating Tylers Life....

I didnt cry when I found out Tyler was in a accident, I didnt cry till I seen him laying there , but when I did Gene Hart looked me straight in the eyes and told me no more crying we are gonna celebrate Tylers 17 years and Ive not cried since.....

Did you know Tyler Liked Ketchup Sandwiches???

Why dont you find out about the person who we were celebrating and write about him??????
#15.1.2.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1 Mark on 10/02/08, 02:06 PM (Reply)
Donna,

I think you miss the bigger picture here. No, I didn't know all those things about Tyler and I doubt either Mr. Buffington or Ms. Schmidd did either. I understand that many people, including you, view this series of articles as insensitive to the families and that has upset those people. However, my argument with Mr. Buffington is about more than just these articles, it revolves around a great journalistic moral than sensitivity. My argument is accuracy. If journalists were completely sensitive to every touchy situation and every family they would never be able to report anything because every story and situation is sure to offend someone. The problem with Mr. Buffington's decision to publish this story isn't that it was offensive, it is that it was offensive because of it was one sided.

Your addition of describing Tyler and explaining his history, likes, styles, and other aspects only makes Mr. Buffington's attempted point more vivid. You rightfully humanize Tyler which clearly makes the alleged events of that day even more ridiculous.

In my opinion your passion is noble but you should consider separating your emotions from your words prior to posting- they are appearing quite immature and unintelligent. Argue your points but argue with integrity and tact. That is just hard to do when emotions are involved.
#15.1.2.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1 SiDonna Marlow-Odum on 10/02/08, 09:34 PM (Reply)
Yes I am emotionally involved simple because I know this family and If I sound like i have a chip on my shoulder well your right.....and until Mike Buffington writes an artical and puts it on the front page of the bcn telling the truth i will keep this chip on my shoulder because it was wrong very wrong it was not the facts and it didnt paint Rita as the Great Person she is and the wonderful child she raised as a single mother. Yes Im very mad very angry and to tell you the truth about it if that was my child and a women done what ms schmid done to rita i would more then likely be in jail.......
#15.1.2.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.2 Mark on 10/02/08, 02:44 PM (Reply)
Your dedication, and somewhat stubborness, is noble. I'll try to make this my last post but can't make any promises, I've sort of enjoyed this little debate with you Mr. Buffington.

If there are 100 different versions of the story how did you decide which one to report? Maybe next time consider publishing more photos which support your story? After all, pictures are worth a thousand words. Why did I have to poke and prod around the discussion forum to get to reveal some of these supporting details? A much more convincing and less controversial article could have been printed had the details been accurate and reported.

The questions you made mention of are by no means outside the scope of the story. You wouldn't have had to wonder what those people were lined up to see had you asked one of them.

And give me a break about her being the only one filing a police report so she is the only one whose story got published. That is ludicrous. By that token there should never be a story published in any Main Street News paper on an event before a police report is filed. Ridiculous.

Yes, the sheriff's deputies should have been the one asking those questions, but since they didn't maybe your reporters could have conducted some investigative reporting(seeing as to that is something your known for) and discovered the answers themselves. Asking questions shouldn't be considered foreign to reporters.

I understand that your reporters can't be at the scene of every story as it unfolds. For me to expect that is ridiculous, so I know they can't attest to the validity of other cars being lined up waiting there turn. I just wonder how the sheriff would know that those cars had even been there to leave if they weren't there when his deputies arrived.

In regards to your last little paragraph, it is just wrong to report a story "regardless of the details." I agree that there is a teen driving problem in Banks County. I am in a position in the county where I interact with teens on a regular basis, many of these teens were good friends with Tyler and Cody. Ashley was only a few years behind me in school and I can recall seeing her around school and watching her play basketball. Their deaths have been rather senseless and something needs to happen which will stop another death. Your story, however, isn't going to have that kind of power.

There is a community problem, but this story isn't necessarily symptomatic of its origin. The details here do make all the difference. You are potentially using the actions of one man to define the culture of a community. Without better, more hardcore evidence that the event was larger than the actions of one 40 year old man who the other adults had no means of controlling, your story lacks the necessary reporting to convince critical minds that this type of event is the cause of three precious lives being cut short. But please keep on trying to solve this problem; just use better journalism by giving equal attention the individual sides of each story and then stepping back to let people figure out what it really means. Of course you should keep writing your editorials and people should realize that editorials are simply the opinions of a person and how they view current events not necessarily the facts of a story. If people don't get that is it their own fault. But if people only get editorials out of what is suppose to be news reporting, that is the newspapers fault. My intentions here haven't been to personally attack you, Ms. Schmidd, your reporters, the BCSO, and definitely not to attack the Bush and Hart families. Instead, I have hoped to display that maybe all the facts weren't presented and we probably shouldn't quite looking for the cause of Banks County's reckless teen driving. Mike, report and report accurately so we can get to the real bottom of the issues.
#15.1.2.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.2.1 Mike Buffington on 10/02/08, 03:25 PM (Reply)
I appreciate your comments and take no offense to them. Whether it was one person or several who were on the road that day "laying drags" (or whatever), my main concern is that it was widely viewed as a "tribute" to someone who had been killed in an auto accident. It is the attitude which endorses such activity more than the action itself which I find troubling. And frankly, many of the comments here have only reinforced the idea that there is something of a "no rules" mentality among some young drivers and their parents in the community. I hope I'm wrong; we will continue to explore that question in the coming months.
#15.1.2.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.2.1.1 SiDonna Marlow-Odum on 10/02/08, 09:19 PM (Reply)
well to you i give no credit...tell the other side of the story...you havent asked anyone who was there what was going on just the ranting of a nosey women who was also in the wrong...
You and your news paper have made Tylers mom sound bad and she isnt she is a wonderful person who has helped many children, she has help them deal with school, home life, and even when there boyfriend and girlfriend have broke there hearts.....She should be praised for what she has done in our school system for our children not condemed for grieving her child.....
One question "What or how would you act if you just buried your child and some nosey women came up to you and started to cuss at you what would you do?
What would you do if you had a pasture full of children dealing with the death of there friend your child????
These children were safe and a good 20 foot away from the fence in there pickup trucks not paying real attention to what was going on in the road, and Rita was strong for them no morning like she could have not hiding somewhere taking care of herself but taking care of Tylers friends and helping them through a hard time not thinking about herself she was thinking of others she always thinks of others
You should of been at the funeral home if you want to really know how great of a person she is she was so strong and so sad at the same time but that side of the story will never be told because no one will as Rita how she feels

Just put yourself in her place and ask yourself would you want this to happen to you would you want the death of your child and the way his life was celebrated plastered all over the front page.....

why dont you give Tyler a tribute and tell everyone how wonderful he was instead of telling everyone how bad our teenagers are...
when it wasnt teenagers acting dumb

this would stop all the bs if you would give Tyler and Rita a front page like you did ms schmid
#15.1.2.1.2 Anonymous on 10/01/08, 05:48 PM (Reply)
I am upset with the fact that it wasn't a teenager in the
car she called to report. it was a 40 year old man. If you
would ask any of the people there they can give you a name
i could but i don't want it in the paper.
#15.2 Jamie on 09/30/08, 12:29 PM (Reply)
I too went to Gainesville during high school. I remember when Evan King died and how devastated everyone was. I did not know him personally, but some of my friends knew him.

But I think comparing our tradition of painting the rock to the people who broke the law by drag racing on a public street is way off base.

The parents of the teenagers in the pasture told them, by their actions, that it was okay to drag race on public streets. I do not believe that is the proper way to handle the situation. However, it is not my place to tell anyone how to raise their children. It is my place, however, to be concerned that people are drag racing on public roads.
#15.2.1 SiDonna Marlow-Odum on 10/01/08, 09:27 AM (Reply)
I will make my point again the teenagers were not drag racing when are you people gonna get this through your thick heads......
#15.2.1.1 Jamie on 10/02/08, 09:52 AM (Reply)
Nowhere in my comment did I say that teenagers were behind the wheel. Maybe you should read things more closely before you make your comments. I do believe that I said the adults were setting a bad example for the teensagers IN THE FIELD, which in no way insinuates that the teenagers were driving.
#16 bcmom on 09/28/08, 06:10 PM (Reply)
I have lived in Banks County for many years and I love it here. I am proud to say that my family is from Banks County. I think the woman had a right to contact law officials and I think they should have investigated the situation. I fault the BCSO for not handling the problem correctly. I also think the paper did the right thing by publishing the report. I have read each and every comment and I feel that we, as a community, have lost the whole point here. We do not need to point fingers, we are all guilty of something, what needs to happen is to come together and support our community but do it wisely. Grieve the lost however you like but remember the safety of others. We, as a community, have lost 3 students in auto related accidents in 18 months and we do not want to loose anymore. How much more can the kids of this community handle? Has anyone thought about that? Our kids have to handle these losses each and every day also. They don't want to loose anymore classmates either! I will agree that this whole situation has gotten blown out of proportion. I don't believe any of this should have been on the front page of the paper but I do believe we have the right to know what is happening in our county. What we all need to remember is we love our children and we don't want to loose any one else!! My prayers go out to the families and friends of Tyler, Cody and Ashley and I also pray that this does not happen again.
#17 Allyson Brannon on 09/28/08, 08:45 PM (Reply)
Well, Mr. Buffington, since you seem the supreme authority on matters such as this, let me ask you why you would choose such a time and such an event to make your personal opinion of "how we do things 'round these parts" known. (In case you didn't pick up on it, that was sarcasm in my previous statement). And who are you to say that I am flat out wrong? I do believe that there is validity in my points.

If you have taken on the role of social reformer, maybe you should look at counties across America. I promise you every single one will have things unique to them that outsiders will deem "strange".

Meaning, you obviously did not grow up around here. (Banks County, not Jefferson)

This is a subject you should never have touched, and it makes clear what kind of person you are. Big fish in a small pond...

Believe what you may and so will I.
Consider me a lost cause Mike.

You may have the last word if you like, as I have been told that is your forte...
#17.1 Mike Buffington, publisher on 09/28/08, 09:10 PM (Reply)
Allyson:
I admire your passion and do not consider you a "lost cause." I hope you go to college and get a degree in journalism and come back home to work for this newspaper. After you go out to cover a few auto wrecks and see EMTs pull the sheet over dead teenagers, then we will continue this discussion.
#18 Allyson Brannon on 09/28/08, 09:27 PM (Reply)
Our differences in opinion remain, however your ability to recognize a shared passion and conviction for what we believe surprised me. Maybe you are not a lost cause either.
#18.1 mg on 09/28/08, 10:48 PM (Reply)
Mike,

Once again you have missed the mark on this article. There was one person that done one stupid thing. You and the Schmid lady turned that into honoring Tyler. That was not honoring Tyler, which one grown man was doing something stupid. However, the people who were gathered in the pasture, on private property, were honoring Tyler. They were passing out t-shirts and stickers. That is how they were honoring Tyler.

Also, where was your retraction on the picture of the car you plastered on the front page to make it look like that was the car "laying the drags". That car had nothing to do with the events of the day.

I completely agree with Mark, this is one side of a two sided story. Unfortunately, you will never give the Bush/Hart family the opportunity to tell their side of the story.

This is a grieving family that is trying to pick up the pieces of their hearts and each week since Tyler's death you and your so called reporting continue to grind those pieces of their hearts into the ground.

In my opinion, which I'm certain does not matter to you; you and the Schmid women are a disgrace to not only this community but to the human race as well. The lack of compassion the two of you have shown the Bush/Hart family is disgusting. Neither they nor Tyler deserved the garbage you have printed in this paper over the past two weeks.
#19 Jessica on 09/28/08, 11:07 PM (Reply)
I think the whole point that you are missing is that the article that was printed last week not only hurt the community, but have you put into consideration that this family just buried their only child and grandson. They have feelings. I don't think you have even thought about how they are taking this whole situation. I think we need to get past what was done after the funeral and come together as a community and stand by this family during this hard time.
#20 SiDonna Marlow-Odum on 09/29/08, 07:08 AM (Reply)
This is for Mike Buffington, Jennifer Schmid, and all the others that are out there judging the way our friend, family, and loved ones grived and are still grieving Tyler....

When you JUDGE another
You dont define them
You define yourself

So I guess you are just as dumb and stupid as the rest of us huh?
#21 Anonymous on 09/29/08, 08:29 AM (Reply)
If the other side of the story should be in the paper for everyone to be able to access, who will be the first to write a letter to the editor? Everyone wants to make comments but very few want to be labeled as the person who made them. (myself included) Why? Because people are so judgemental and if an adult makes a comment-their family, friends and aquaintances have to be subjected to cruelty whether or not the opinion is shared or not.
I appreciate the fact that this lady was brave enough to face the people and state her believes as to what she felt they were doing wrong. I wasn't there and don't know what manner she used in portraying the tribute but I am a mother of a child at BCMS and am extememly concerned that Rita Bush is a "counselor" there when based on this story, she definitely is having a very hard time emotionally. I am deeply saddened at the loss of Tyler and Cody. I extend my sympathy to both families. I hope that it is a very long time before our county faces another loss like this and I hope our adults and teenagers learn from mistakes made.
#22 Cindi Jordan on 09/29/08, 10:23 AM (Reply)
For those too afraid to even sign your names you really don't have a right for your words to be read. Tyler was my nephew and you people need to leave his mom alone to come to grips with the tradagy that she is going through. What this paper and the rude people who do not even know the family put Rita and her family through is beyond belief. I know Rita and am sure she is being as brave as any mom in her situation could be. With her belief in God and knowing that Tyler is with his dad now I'm sure Rita is going to be fine if you just let her. Tyler and Kenny will be missed by all that knew and loved them. Rita keep the faith, knowing someday we will all get to sing with the angels.

Jennifer Schmid, hows that 15 minutes of fame going. (sorry but I'm human and just could not resist).
#23 Tara on 09/29/08, 12:30 PM (Reply)
Who made you KING Mr. Buffington? For you to say that your opinon is RIGHT and the people who don't agree with you are WRONG is just plain DUMB. And I would like to see where someone has ever died for laying drags.And just to let you know laying drags is not drag racing. I know you think you are a smart man but if you don't know the difference in those 2 your you really need to go back to highschool
#24 bcmom on 09/29/08, 02:11 PM (Reply)
Mike, just get the other side of the story and put it on the front page and let this all rest. The original story should not have been published front page anyway, and many feel not published at all. It has become a ridiculous situation.

Ms. Schmid did what she thought was right - she may not have handled the situation correctly..so yes that is her fault but does the rest of us handle unnerving situations the right way?? Absolutely not.

I have a student who is at BCMS and I do not have the right to decide if Rita is capable of handling her job-that is for the administration to monitor. I have BCHS student also who is there everyday dealing with the loss of these students.

He that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone. I believe too many stones have been cast in this situation. What everyone needs to do is get off your high-horses and just hush. Parents take responsibility for your actions, Ms. Schmid, county officials and officers do the same. May these children rest in peace, may God bless these families and friends who are hurting at the loss of THEIR loved one.

Our children are reading all these comments and seeing how adults act...what are we teaching them???

The Lord shall judge his people. He alone has that right not any of us.
#25